Yogi, Take Me to a Higher Place …

May 30th, 2008 by Administrator

The New York Times has published a number of informative articles on yoga and meditation this week, in particular Lotus Therapy, from Tuesday’s Science Times, and A Super Highway to Bliss, from the Sunday Style section. I recommend reading both of these! Each addresses the neurological impact of mindfulness meditation in different ways. Then there was this week’s New York Times Thursday Style Fitness article Yoga, Take Me to a Higher Place, which has been the subject of a number of my recent conversations.

It is commendable that the New York Times reserved the entire Style Fitness section to write about yoga. While the article was well-written, it was still a bit disjointed and kind of missing some points about yoga. In brief, the story addresses the “problem” that advanced yoga practitioners in New York and other major cities are unable to find enough challenging classes to suit their needs, despite the fact that there are yoga studios springing up on every corner. It even addresses the task of finding as advanced class as “arduous”.

Sundar flying crow
Asana are important, but there is much more. Sundar performing flying crow beautifully.

Overall, the article seemed to gauge one’s level of yoga by how well one can manipulate the physical body. Sure, we can contort ourselves into crazy positions, but perhaps it’s a bigger challenge to focus on the subtleties of a single posture and exercise patience. Asana, after all, are just one small (but still important and therapeutic) component of “yoga” (ashtanga and hatha yoga). The postures are tools to help the individual become more grounded, compassionate, and centered for meditation. There are a few quotes from members of the yoga community, such as Annie Carpenter of Santa Monica’s Yoga Works and Cynthia Lee of OM Yoga in New York, that remind the reader of this. These statements, however, are hardly extended upon. The author touches upon pranayama and meditation, but quickly shifts back to the subject of how deeper “poses” define advanced yoga.

Categorizing asana classes by level is important and class distinctions should be respected to honor the yogic tradition and prevent injuries. These delineations, however, should not nurture competitiveness. My teachers in New York and India, who I respect so deeply for selflessly and devotedly pursuing the path of yoga over a course many years, would never label themselves as accomplished or “advanced”. It’s just not about that. I believe that the article would have been more powerful, engaging, and well-rounded had the author firmly addressed the fact that asana is far from everything, instead of stressing how advanced students are “suffering” from a lack of higher-level classes.

As a New Yorker, I also found that the article omits a number of wonderful yoga studios in New York that offer “advanced” and serious classes, such as the Iyengar Institute, Dharma Mittra, and a number of other well-known studios (focusing on Mysore Ashtanga, Anusara, and more). Nor does it shed light on any of the wonderful institutions that focus on exercising the mind, such as meditation centers like the Integral Yoga and Tibet House.

Mother Teresa
Mother Teresa.

Posted in Asana, Mindfulness, Yoga

3 Responses

  1. “Yogi, Take Me to a Higher Place” at Yoga Nation

    […] Sophieherbert.com: This blog by Sophie Herbert points out what the article was missing–although if I had included everything, it would have been a booklet. She says this, “My teachers in New York and India, who I respect so deeply for selflessly and devotedly pursuing the path of yoga over a course many years, would never label themselves as accomplished or “advanced”.” […]

  2. Roland

    I loved the beautifully written “My Stroke of Insight - a Brain Scientist’s Personal Journey” by Jill Bolte Taylor and her incredible talk on TED dot com. Dr. Taylor’s unique perspective as a Harvard neuroanatomist having a stroke, combined with her sensitivity and awareness, produced something as powerful as I’ve ever witnessed. I want to share Dr Taylor’s story far and wide because it’s a wonderful story and a great book to read, but more importantly, this is the message we desperately need if we are to survive as a species.

  3. steve Yoga DVD Dude

    Good points. In the west the ego is concerned with advanced postures. There are good reasons to practice advanced postures but ego security and advancement is not usually one of them. The ego will take care of itself if one simply practices yoga in a style and manner similar to the way one cleans the room. You simply attend to what is in front of you and eventually things get done.

    Namaste , Steve Yoga Video and DVD Dude at MyYogaVideo.com

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.

About a bit more about yoga…

A bit more about yoga is written by Sophie Herbert, a yoga practitioner/teacher and visual artist from New York City. Hope you enjoy the blog!